Ellen Lee, Euphonium & Tuba
Picture
  • Home
  • Bio
  • Private Lessons
  • Listen
  • Resources
  • Tuba-Zine
  • Euphonium + Electronics Consortium

3/25/2026

The Perfect Tape

0 Comments

Read Now
 
In 2021, in the midst of the world burning and nothing about live music making sense, I entered my first ever euphonium competition. I was 20 years old, a sophomore at the University of Kentucky, fighting my way through seriously playing with electronics for the first time and trying to submit for Falcone. I had been playing the piece since the repertoire list was released to the public in August, and I had booked a session with one of Lexington's best recording professionals, so I was feeling great going in to the recording session, but one thing I hadn't accounted for as a younger and newer musician was the happenings of live music, the mistakes, and the downward spiral that would happen each time I made one.

Somewhere along the way, many of us internalize a quiet but powerful belief:

There exists a “perfect” take, and we just have to keep trying until we get it.

In the age of digital recording, it’s easy to assume that perfection is the standard. We listen back with hyper-critical ears, noticing every chipped note, every breath, every moment that doesn’t align with our ideal.

So we try again.
And again.
And again.


And what starts as thoughtful preparation can quickly spiral into chasing something unattainable.
So what’s the problem? Well, despite what some musicians on social media show us, perfection is not the same thing as excellence in music.

A “perfect” take, something that we think to be completely free of flaws, can often be musically lifeless. When we focus exclusively on eliminating mistakes, we risk stripping away the very things that make our playing compelling like phrasing, risk-taking, character, and humanity. Your intonation could be perfect, you could play everything on the page just how it was written, as fast as possible, as clean as possible. But something will still be missing.

From a tuba/euphonium perspective, especially for the recorded rounds of competitions, judges aren’t sitting behind a computer screen with a checklist of minor imperfections, or at least I hope they aren’t.
They’re (again, hopefully) asking bigger questions:
  • Does this musician have a clear musical voice?
  • Is there a sense of phrasing and direction?
  • Are they communicating something intentional?
  • Do they sound like someone I want to keep listening to?

Yes, accuracy matters. But musicianship should be the priority. A take with small imperfections but strong musical direction will almost always be more compelling than a sterile, overly cautious “perfect” run.
One of the most helpful mindset shifts that I had when recording for competitions this year is this:
Recording is not a pass/fail test, it is a process of discovery.
Instead of treating every take as “the one,” I learned to treat recording sessions as an extension of my practice. I have to take the time to:
  • Learn more about how I sound under pressure
  • Refine my musical decisions
  • Build consistency over time
Some of my best takes happened when I wasn’t trying to force perfection and when I simply focused on making music.

Here are a few ways I work to keep my mindset grounded:

1. Taking time to review each take before the next
Give yourself time to listen back to what was recorded. Take notes on what was good, what was great, and what little reminders do you need to write in your music before the next go ‘round? If you have the tendency to dwell on the negatives like I do, put more focus into what was good that you want to replicate in the next take. We all know what we want to fix, we know what notes we missed, we know that we took a weird breath in measure 27. But what do we want to continue to do? What are we already accomplishing in these tapes that show off our identity and maturity as a musician?


2. Define “Good Enough” Ahead of Time
Before you hit record, decide what you’re willing to accept. This could be a small list of simple things like:
  • Strong musical interpretation
  • Solid tone and intonation
  • Minor imperfections are allowed (and they will happen!)
If you wait to define this after recording, your standards will keep shifting. You don’t want to leave yourself with the idea that you’re having to settle for a tape because you didn’t set expectations ahead of time.

3. Record Full Runs More Often
Especially for tuba and euphonium players, endurance and pacing matter. Don’t just patch together excerpts of a piece mentally, actually practice recording complete runs so your body and mind know what that feels like. I like to use my phone to record in the practice room, and during practice sessions (and at different times during these sessions) I like to record a full run of a piece just to see what happens. Again, we’re refining ideas and building consistency. Don’t surprise yourself when you record with the intention of submitting that tape.


4. Take Breaks (Seriously)
Fatigue, both physical and mental, can sabotage our chance at success. Step away, reset your ears, and come back fresh. My favorite part about recording at Michigan is that there are always people in the studio recording for the same competitions as you. When we recorded for Falcone this semester, our brilliant collaborative pianist Liz would have us rotate after recording a take, giving us the opportunity to reset and take a break, grab some water, get some fresh air, chat, etc. This took the feeling of the clock ticking to the end away and made the entire experience way more relaxing, and you might even find that listening to others play the same piece is pretty inspiring. Also schedule multiple sessions if you have the means to, and remind yourself it is okay if the first session wasn’t a total success. This process takes time, patience, and bravery.


5. Listen Like a Teacher, Not a Critic
When you review your recordings, ask:
  • What worked musically?
  • Where did I communicate well?
  • What would I tell a student to adjust?

This keeps your feedback constructive instead of punishing. I used these questions when working with one of my own students who was recording for Falcone this year. We would record a take and I’d give her a minute to reflect and we’d talk through some things before trying again. This allowed both of us to take some of the pressure of perfection out of our minds, but as a younger student, she still got the comfort in knowing that I was there to affirm her musical choices and help her make small adjustments (and I have to say that I am more excited about her final product than I am my own, she is an absolute rockstar).


Instead of our marker of success being “I recorded a flawless take,” what should it be instead?
This month I have found myself asking questions like this, and I invite you to adopt them as your own:
  • “I recorded something that represents my musical voice.”
  • “I played with intention and clarity.”
  • “I captured a performance I can stand behind.”

To me, these make “success” a much more meaningful and achievable thing.

At the end of the day, if the “perfect tape” has the potential to exist, I probably won't be the person to record it, and that is fine by me. My job isn’t to prove that I can play without mistakes. My job is to make people feel something worth remembering.

So the next time you hit “record,” take a breath and remind yourself:

I am not a robot.
I am not chasing perfection.
I am sharing meaningful music.


Good luck to everyone wrapping up their recording process for various festivals and competitions approaching this summer, and remember to be kind to yourself.

​
© 2026 Ellen Katherine Lee

Share

0 Comments
Details

    About Tuba-Zine!

    Tuba-Zine was created to give a space to tuba and euphonium community members to share ideas and inspiration with others in a space that is free to access. I will post updates from my practice room, my studio, and  from my travels, but I also want to emphasize the goings on of other collegiate and freshly post-grad musicians, as work is often looked over for publication due to how long or short someone's CV is.

    Do you want your work posted on Tuba-Zine? Please contact me and send me some stuff! I post as I receive materials for the blog or if I have something going on that I want to share, so there is room for everyone!

    What Tuba-Zine posts:
    - Tuba-euphonium or tuba-euph adjacent research
    - Information and reviews about new works for tuba-euphonium
    - Spotlight posts about solo musicians and tuba-euph chamber groups
    - Reviews on recitals, concerts, conferences, and other things happening in the community
    - Repertoire roundups: covering what rep is chosen for competitions, community opinions on the pieces, and links to reliable recordings
    - And more! Send me all of the interesting and cool things!

    Tuba-Zine is free for everyone, and I am one person on a doctoral student budget, so I can't compensate anyone for contributions, but contributors get full credit for their material and can plug their contacts and social media handles. If you have any questions about this, please let me know!

      Submit something for Tuba-Zine!

      Give a brief outline of the submission. Is it a musician or chamber group spotlight, your research on underwater tuba playing, or maybe an album review? Tell me here and I will email you for further info!
    Submit

    Archives

    April 2026
    March 2026

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Quick Links

About Ellen
Resources
Listen

Contact

Contact Me
Find a Teacher
Submit an Idea for Tuba-Zine
© COPYRIGHT 2015. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
  • Home
  • Bio
  • Private Lessons
  • Listen
  • Resources
  • Tuba-Zine
  • Euphonium + Electronics Consortium